# I. Introduction lobally, about 800 women die from pregnancy or labor related complications around the world every day. Two hundred eighty-seven thousand women died during pregnancy and childbirth in 2010; more than half of these deaths occur in Africa. The ratio of maternal mortality in the Sub-Saharan Africa region is one of the highest, reaching 686 per 100,000 live births [1]. In Ethiopia, according to 2016EDHS, the estimated maternal mortality ratio was found to be 412 per 100,000 live births [2]. The existence of maternal health service alone does not guarantee their use by women [3]. The World Health Organization promotes skilled attendance at every birth to reduce maternal mortality and recommends that women's satisfaction be assessed to improve the quality and effectiveness of health care [4]. Client satisfaction is a subjective and dynamic perception of the extent to which the expected health care is received [5]. It is not important whether the patient is right or wrong, but what is important is how the patient feels [6]. Studies done in Dhaka, Bangladesh, and South Australia showed that the level of maternal satisfaction with delivery care was 92.3% and 86.1%, respectively [7,8]. However, the level of satisfaction among laboring mothers in African countries is not enough; only 51.9% and 56% of mothers were satisfied with delivery services in South Africa and Kenya, respectively [9,10]. Ethiopian studies done in Amharic Referral Hospitals and Azuela Hospital revealed 61.9% and 80.7% satisfaction of mothers on delivery services, respectively [11,12]. Satisfaction with delivery service is a multidimensional construct embracing satisfaction with self (personal control), and with the physical environment of delivery ward and quality of care [13]. The mother's satisfaction during the birthing process is the most frequently reported indicators in the evaluation of the quality of maternity services [14]. Dimensions of care that may influence client satisfaction include: Health care Provider client interaction, Service provision, G physical environment, access, bureaucracy and attention to psychosocial problems. Many factors influence women's satisfaction during delivery: certain demographic characteristics have been predominantly studied in relation to satisfaction during delivery services. For example, a study done in Sweden (n=2762) reported that younger women had more negative expectations related to childbirth and they experienced more pain and lack of control during labor compared with older women [15], while another study done in Brazil (n = 15,688) showed no age related difference in women's satisfaction with childbirth services [16]. Studies from developing countries show that satisfaction with services had a negative association with the amount of time women spent at the health facility before childbirth [17]. The educational level of women in different studies and settings has demonstrated positive, negative or nil association with satisfaction during delivery services [18,19]. Other identified factors that influenced satisfaction with childbirth services are: having clean and orderly labor rooms and women-friendly delivery processes, such as having been prepared in advance for what to expect during the labor/postpartum/breast feeding period; involvement in the decision-making process; having a birth plan and being able to follow it; having pain relief during labor; having a birth companion and respectful care providers; receiving help from care providers in performing self and neonate 'scare; and experiencing less symptoms in the postpartum period [20][21][22][23][24][25]. A woman's obstetric history, mode of delivery, and her feelings towards recent childbirth can also affect maternal satisfaction. For example: being multifarious, preferring a spontaneous vaginal delivery and being able to have a spontaneous vaginal birth [26,27] enhances the women's satisfaction with giving birth. Qualitative studies on Indian women's experiences and opinions on giving birth at a health facility reveal that they are not fully satisfied during delivery service, primarily due to the long waiting time before they meet a healthcare provider, having few opportunities to communicate with providers, not being involved in decision-making, and having stern care providers [28][29][30][31][32]; however, they settle for childbirth services perceived as 'essential' for safe childbirth rather than 'desirable' for a pleasant experience [33][34][35][36]. While the community's access to institutional delivery has improved, the assumption that accessibility is synonymous with quality of care, especially among policymakers, gives concern. This study aimed to assess women's satisfaction with an institutional delivery service using a standardized scale with intent to potentially use the findings in advocacy for service improvement. Studying the quality of institutional delivery service from client perspective will provide systematic information for service providers, decision makers, local planners and other stakeholders help understand to what extent the service is functioning according to clients' perception, and what changes might be required to meet clients' need as well as to increase utilization of the service by the target population. This study serves both knowledge generation and delivery service quality improvement purpose. The findings of this study can be used by local planners and decision makers to improve the quality of institutional delivery service. # II. Methods # a) Study Design and Period Cross-sectional study was conducted at Abrade Swede Memorial Primary hospital, from February 8, 2017 to September 25, 2017. # b) Study Area Abrade Swede Memorial primary Hospital is found in Brevity administration 410 kilometers away from Addis Ababa and 155kilometers away from Bahia Dar the capital city of Amharic regional state. The hospital primarily serves for four worked as: Bore, Bore city, Shindig and Shekel. using a single population proportion formula, which took the proportion of overall satisfaction at 65.2% % [6], with a margin of error of 0.05 at the 95% confidence interval (CI). Adding 10% non-response rate, the final sample size was calculated to be 420 patients. From the hospital pervious report about delivery, average number of clients who delivered in the hospital was 110 per month. Therefore the number of participants who visited the hospital was estimated for the study period; then sampling fraction for selecting the study participants was determined by dividing with the total estimated number of patients during the data collection period to the total sample size which was calculated to be two. The first study participant was selected by lottery method among the list from one to five; the next study participant was identified systematically in every two intervals until the required sample size was achieved. # f) Data Collection Procedure and Quality Assurance A validated structured questionnaire prepared by the Ethiopian Ministry of Health to assess maternal satisfaction was used according to the objectives of the study and the local situation of the study area in Amharic language. Then the questionnaire was translated to English to assure consistency of the tool. Pre-testing was conducted on 20 respondents at Bore Health center delivery attendants. # g) Data Management and Data Analysis The collected data were checked for completeness and consistency before being coded, entered and analyzed using SPSS version 16. Summary statistics of socio demographic variables were presented using frequency tables. Bi-variable analysis was done and variables with p-value less than 0.2 were included in the multiple variable analysis of logistic regression. The odds ratio and 95% confidence intervals were also computed at p-value of 0.05. # h) Ethical Consideration The research was approved by AsradeZewude Memorial Primary Hospital Senior Management Committee. Permission to conduct the study was also obtained from AsradeZewude Memorial hospital maternity case team. During data collection, the purpose of the study was clearly explained to the participants, and informed oral consent was obtained. To ensure confidentiality and privacy no identity was linked to the questionnaire. # III. Result a) Socio Demographic Characteristics of the Respondents A total of 420 clients after delivery were involved in this study. As shown in Table 1, 60% of the respondents were between 15-24 years of age, 90% were married, 70% of the delivery was spontaneous, and 70% of clients came to hospital by ambulance. SAG =strongly agree, AG=agree, NAG =Not agree, DAG= disagree and SDAG=strongly disagree c) Maternal satisfaction with physical facilities Only 50% strongly agreed and 20% agreed that there was a functional Maternity ward toilet, hand washing and shower during their labor and delivery time (Table 3). # d) Maternal satisfaction with Service provision The majority of participants (60% strongly agreed and 40% agreed) responds positively to the questionnaire 'I have got a bed immediately' (Table 4). # e) Overall satisfaction Overall satisfaction was measured on 10 scales, 1 worst and 10 the best. Those who scored 6 and above was considered 'yes' for satisfaction. Their intention to recommend others to the hospital was measured using yes (87%) and No (13%) options (Table 5). The regression output of factors for maternal satisfaction showed that mothers who think of the welcoming hospital environment was 3.09(2.30-2.69) times more likely to satisfy than those who perceive the hospital environment was not welcoming (Table 6). # IV. Discussion In this study, the overall satisfaction of mothers on delivery service was found to be 88%, which was comparable to the study conducted in Wolayita Zone (82.9%), Debremarkos town (81.7%) and Azuela Hospital (80.7%) [9,11,17]. However, it was higher than the study, which was conducted in Jimmy (77%) [19] and Amphora Referral Hospitals (61.9%) [12] In Ethiopia and South Africa (51.9%) and Kenya (56%) in Africa [9,10]. The difference with the above finding may be because of a real difference in the quality of services provided, expectation of mothers or the type of health facilities. Maternal educational status was significantly and inversely associated with their level of satisfaction with delivery services. Those respondents who were never educated were 2.15 more likely to satisfy with delivery service than whose educational level is diploma and above. This finding supports the study conducted in Azuela Hospital and other foreign literatures. The literatures showed that clients had various expectations about hospital delivery that influenced their perception of care [11,18]. This study revealed that those who came to the hospital by ambulance were 3.15 times more likely to satisfy than those who came on foot. This finding was related to accessibility as explained by other similar studies [12,24]. Maternal level of satisfaction was also related to creating welcoming environment hospital to laboring mothers. Those clients who consider the hospital as welcoming environment were 3.09 times more likely to satisfy with maternal service. There was a strong association between maternal levels of satisfaction and respectful delivery care providers. Those participants who thought that care providers were respectful were 6.85 times more likely to satisfy with the delivery service. Perception of respondents of labor pain management was associated with level of maternal satisfaction. Those who answered yes were 4.51 times more likely to satisfy than who answered no to proper labor pain management, according to their perception. Attention to laboring mother's concern was also related to the maternal level of satisfaction. Those who thought their questions and concerns were answered during labor were 3.61 times more likely to satisfy than who thought not. # V. Conclusion The aim of this study was to assess levels of maternal satisfaction and associated factors with delivery service at the AsradeZewude Memorial primary hospital. The overall maternal satisfaction with the delivery service was found to be 88%. Even though the result was slightly higher than the previous studies conducted in Ethiopia, there are still unmet needs and expectations of mothers during labor and delivery that the hospital should focus as delivery service quality improvement area. The identified associated factors were access to ambulance service, welcoming hospital environment, proper labor pain management, respectful care and listening to their questions. # VI. Recommendations a) Recommendation to AsradeZewude Memorial primary Hospital The hospital shall better consider physical barriers to create a welcoming hospital environment for maternal service. The hospital should facilitate ambulance access for delivering mothers. # b) Recommendation to health care providers The care providers should manage labor pain properly when providing service; it should be with compassionate and respectful. The care provider should meet the social and psychological concerns of the delivering mothers. # c) Limitation The feelings associated with childbirth itself, due to limited opportunities of exploration in quantitative studies, pose some confounders like the 'halo effect' a positive attitude towards successfully give birth makes it difficult to separate childbirth satisfaction from satisfaction with childbirth services. Participants' tendencies to rate services more positive in general are another known confounder. Participants' subjectivity being pleased with services that are not necessarily evidence based poses another confounder for quantitative studies measuring satisfaction. This study was not funded by any agency, but the motivation came from AsradeZewude Primary Hospital quality improvement unit as part of maternal service quality improvement. The quality improvement unit had no involvement in the design, data collection and analysis, write-up, and decision for the results to be published, but it needed only the report or result to design delivery service quality improvement plan accordingly. 1VariablesCategoriesN%Age15 -242526025 -34842035 -44631545-50215Marital statusSingle82Married37890Widowed41Divorced/Separated297EducationNever attended school16840Primary and junior education16840High school education4210Diploma and above4210Gravid(pregnancies)1-3374894-642107-94110-1200Previous InstitutionalYes12630deliveryNo29470Means of deliverySpontaneous vaginal delivery29470Caesarian section8420Instrumental4210 2Level of agreementVariables5 =4 =3 =2 =1 =SAGAGNAGDAGSDAGThe hospital is welcoming, starting from the gate90%10%000The care providers listen and answer all my questions during delivery50%20%010%20%All the care given to me was with my consent during labor90%10%000The care I received was respect full90%10%000I was counseled about breast feeding, vaccination and others after delivery60%20%10%10%0The health care providers introduced themselves to me70%020%10%0During labor and delivery my pain was properly managed80%14%0%06% 3Level of agreementVariables5 =4 =3 =2 =1 =SAGAGNAGDAGSDAGGetting the maternity unit is easy starting from the gate90%10%000Maternity ward toilets, hand washing and shower were functional during my labor and delivery50%20%010%20%Cleanness of the ward was good during my labor and delivery90%10%000My privacy was secured during my labor and delivery90%10%000I used my preferred position during my labor and delivery60%20%10%10%0I was allowed to have my families on my side during my labor and delivery70%020%10%0 4Level of agreementVariables5 =4 =3 =2 =1 =SAGAGNAGDAGSDAGI w other procedures as directed to the maternity ward immediately without recording and90%010%00I was seen by the care provider immediately I have got the maternity ward90%10%000I have got a bed immediately60%40%000All those diagnostic tests prescribed for me were available in the hospital90%10%000All those drugs and supplies needed were available in the hospital90%10%000 5YesNo 6Year 201825Variables level of Educationnever educatedMaternal satisfaction Satisfied Not satisfied 148(35%) 20(5%)COR(95%CI) 3.09 (1.34-7.14)AOR(95%CI) 2.15(1.02-3.71)Volume XVIII Issue III Version Ifirst level148(35%)20(5%)2.01(1.00-3.02)2.01(0.99-3.10)D D D D )high school37(9%)5(1%)1.99(1.00-2.03)1.56(0.85-2.96)(means of delivery Means of transportation Previous institutional delivery The hospital is welcoming starting from the gate I was directed to the maternity ward immediately without recording and other procedures The care I received was respect fulldiploma and above Natural C/S Instrumental Ambulance Public transport Private or Contract On foot Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes No37(9%) 259(62%) 73(17%) 37(9%) 259(62%) 74(18%) 4(1%) 32(7%) 111(26%) 259(62%) 328(78%) 41(10%) 331(80%) 39(8%) 328(78%) 41(10%)5(1%) 36(9%) 10(2%) 5(1%) 36(9%) 10(2%) 0 5(1%) 15(4%) 35(8%) 45(11%) 6(1%) 45(11%) 5(1%) 45(11%) 6(1%)1 2.60 (1.15-5.89) 1.29 (0.53-3.10) 1 2.99(2.50-3.66) 1.40(1.01-1.95) 0.21 (0.05-0.90) 1 1 3.31(2.32-2.66) 1 1.99(0.99-1.05) 1 6.02(4.01-6.65) 1 2.05(1.02-2.03)1 3.15(1.02-3.78) 2.01(0.99-3.19) 1.53(0.81-2.91) 1 3.09(2.30-2.69) * * 1 6.85(4.35-6.95) * * 1Global Journal of Medical ResearchI was allowed to have my familiesYes328(78%)45(11%)0.95(0.52-0.99)on my side during my labor and deliveryNo41(10%)6(1%)1I used my preferred position duringYes328(78%)45(11%)0.58(0.15-0.60)my labor and deliveryNo41(10%)6(1%)1Cleanness of the ward was goodYes328(78%)46(11%)4.01(3.02-4.99)during my labor and deliveryNo41(10%)6(1%)1Maternity ward toilet, hand washingYes207(49%)28(7%)3.21(2.20-3.52)3.21(2.20-3.52)and shower was functional during my labor and deliveryNo163(39%)22(5%)11During labor and delivery my painYes328(78%)45(11%)5.51(3.56-5.91)4.51(3.12-5.01) * *was properly managedNo41(10%)6(1%)11 © 2018 Global Journals 1 © 2018 Global Journals ## Acknowledgements The author is extremely grateful to the women who gave their time in completing the questionnaires and AsradeZewude Memorial Primary Hospital Senior Management for ethical approval of the study. Contributors: GDA generates the idea of the study, design the study, wrote the proposal, collected the data, organized and analyzed, finally wrote the result of the study. Competing interests: None declared. Patient consent: Verbal consent obtained. Data sharing Statement: The data collected for this study can be obtained from the author upon a reasonable request. * World Bank Group, and United Nations Population Division Trends in Maternal Mortality: 1990 to 2015 Geneva: World Health Organization JBong Arts Who Unicef Unfpa 10.1111/padr.12033 Population and Development Review 42 4 2016. 2015 * Wealth of Information on Global Health, World Health Organization 2013. 2013 World Health Organization * Available at DhsEthiopian 2016 * Making Pregnancy Safer: The Critical Role of the Skilled Attendant: A Joint Statement by WHOM, ICM, FIGO, World Health Organization (WHO) World Health Organization 2004 * Defining Patient-Perceived Quality of Nursing Care JHLatrobe LVBolden 10.1097/00001786-200110000-00005 Journal of Nursing Care Quality 16 1 2001 Ovid Technologies Internet * DEAulis NIBunked APLogorrhea 1997 * Identifying Predictors of Satisfaction with Access to Medical Care and Quality of Care American Journal of Medical Quality SAGE Publications Internet * 10.1177/0885713x9701200103 12 * Patient Satisfaction with Maternal and Child Health Service among Mothers Attending the Maternal and Child Health Training in DahakaBangeladish AHasan JChompikul .UBunyan 2007 Marisol University * Maternity Service in South Australia Public Hospital: Patient Satisfaction Survey Research 2007 Australian Government, South Australia Australia Australian Government * Patients' satisfaction with midwifery services in a regional hospital and its referring clinics in the Limpopo Province of South Africa TGLumadiande Bunch Africa Journal of Nursing and Midwifery 13 2 2011 * Women's satisfaction with delivery care in Nairobi's informal settlements EvaSBezant MichaelAKoenig 10.1093/intqhc/mzn058 International Journal for Quality in Health Care 21 2 2009 * Maternal Satisfaction with the Delivery Services in Azuela Hospital RARmesfintafa 2014. 2013 OMICS Publishing Group Arsis Zone, Roomier Region, Ethiopia Internet * 10.4172/2161-0932.1000257 * Mother s 'satisfaction with referral hospital delivery service in Amphora Region, Ethiopia ATayelgn DTZegeye Kebede BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth 11 2011. 2011 * Factors determining satisfaction among facility-based maternity clients in Nepal SMehta YRPaddle MDaring KKArial SPaddle RMehta 2017 Internet * 10.1186/s12884-017-1532-0 Springer Nature 25 1 17 * Factors related to childbirth satisfaction PGoodman MCMackey ASTawakoni Journal of Advanced Nursing 2004 Internet * Wiley-Blackwell * 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2003.02981.x 46 * Measures of satisfaction with care during labor and birth: a comparative review ASawyer SAyers JAbbott GGate HRaba LDuly 10.1186/1471-2393-13-108 Nature 8 1 13 2013 Springer * Maternal Satisfaction on Delivery Service and Its Associated Factors among Mothers Who Gave Birth in Public Health Facilities of DebreMarkos Town KBite MAyichiluhm KImam 2015 Northwest Ethiopia Internet * 10.1155/2015/460767 * Satisfaction with caregivers during labor among low risk women in the Netherlands: the association with planned place of birth and transfer of care during labor CCGreets JVan Dillon TClomp AlmLargo-Janssen JorgeADe 10.1186/s12884-017-1410-9 2017 Springer Nature 17 * Determinants of women's satisfaction with maternal health care: a review of literature from developing countries ASrivastava BIAvon PRajbangsi SBhattacharyya 10.1186/s12884-015-0525-0 2015 Springer Nature 15 * Mothers' Satisfaction with Institutional Delivery Service in Public Health Facilities of Omro Nada District, Jimmy Zone 'BHailer Tads 10.11648/j.cmr.20170601.13 Clinical Medicine Research 6 1 23 2017 Science Publishing Group * First TimeMothers? Pregnancy and Birth Experiences Varying by Age. Obstetric Anesthesia Digest ECastoff ESchist UWaldenström 2008 Internet * Ovid Technologies (Walters Lower Health) 10.1097/01.aoa.0000319784.93395.58 28 * Desigualdadessociais e satisfactory das mushers com o atendimentoaoparto no Brazil: estudonacional de base hospital ED' Orsk OMBridgeman CsgDenis JMAugier De CRGuzman JATorres 2014 Cavernous de SaúdePública Internet * FapUNIFESP (Silo) * 10.1590/0102-311x00087813 30 * What women want: qualitative analysis of consumer evaluations of maternity care in Queensland LCMckinnon SJProsser YDMiller 2014 Internet * 10.1186/s12884-014-0366-2 Springer Nature 14 1 * Factors Related to Women's Childbirth Satisfaction in Physiologic and Routine Childbirth Groups EJavari PMohebbi SMazloomzadeh Iran J Knurs Midwifery Res 22 2017 * The Mistreatment of Women during Childbirth in Health Facilities Globally: A Mixed-Methods Systematic Review MABohlen JPVogel ECHunter OLusty SKMach JPSouza 2015 * RJukes Medicine 10.1371/journal.pmed e1001847 Public Library of Science (Plus) 12 6 Internet * Client satisfaction of maternity care in Loretta province Iran FChange AIrajpour MSomber Iran Knurs Midwifery Res 20 2015 * Women's perception of quality of maternity services: a longitudinal survey in Nepal RKaree AHLee PKPokharel 10.1186/1471-2393-14-45 2014 Springer Nature 14 * Experiences of and responses to disrespectful maternity care and abuse during childbirth; a qualitative study with women and men in Morogoro Region SAMcmahon ASGeorge JJChabot IHMoshe RNPembina PJWinch 10.1186/1471-2393-14-268 2014 Springer Nature 14 Tanzania * Assessment of client satisfaction in labor and delivery services at a maternity referral hospital in Ethiopia TMelees YGebrehiwot DBastogne DHabit 10.11604/pamj.2014.17.76.3189 Pan African Medical Journal [Internet]. Pan African Medical Journal 17 2014 * Assessment of social psychological determinants of satisfaction with childbirth in a cross-national perspective WChristians PBracken 10.1186/1471-2393-7-26 2007 Springer Nature 7 * Satisfaction with Maternal and Newborn Health Care Following Childbirth Measure FTCamacho CSWeisman RTAnderson MMHillemeier EWSchaefer IMPaul 2012 PsycTESTS Dataset [Internet * 10.1037/t31978-000 APA * Comparative study analyzing women's childbirth satisfaction and obstetric outcomes across two dif-ferment models of maternity care setting: 2univer-sity hospitals in south eastern Spain BCFerrier MCJordan CBMessenger Br Med J 6 2016 * Factors influencing women's preference for health facility deliveries in Jharkhand state, India: a cross sectional analysis SBhattacharyya ASrivastava RRoy BIAvon 10.1186/s12884-016-0839-6 2016 Springer Nature 16 * A study on utilization of JananiSurakshaYojana and its association with institutional delivery in the state of West Bengal SMukhopadhyay DMukhopadhyay SMali SKayak Biwa's A 'Biwa A India. Indian Journal of Public Health 2016 Internet * 10.4103/0019-557x.184543 Medknow 60 2 118 * A spatial analysis to study access to emergency obstetric transport services under the public private "Janine Express Yolanda YSade DeCosta ADivan V 2014 program in two districts of * IndiaReproductiveMadhya Pradesh Health Internet * 10.1186/1742-4755-11-57 Springer Nature 11 * Client satisfaction on maternal and child health services in rural Bengal RPal PDas MBase TTirade Biwa's G PMerida Indian Journal of Community Medicine 2010 Internet * Medknow * Understanding and measuring quality of care: dealing with complexity. Bulletin of the World Health Organization JHandfed TPowell-Jackson DBalabanova 2017 WHO Press Internet * 10.2471/blt.16.179309 95